Current:Home > NewsSouth Carolina Supreme Court to decide if new private school voucher program is legal -CoinMarket
South Carolina Supreme Court to decide if new private school voucher program is legal
View
Date:2025-04-19 02:38:05
COLUMBIA, S.C. (AP) — The South Carolina Supreme Court heard arguments Wednesday on whether a law passed last year allowing parents to spend taxpayer money on private schools violates part of the he state constitution banning direct aid to anything other than public schools.
But even as the justices ponder the case, lawmakers in the House are looking to expand the program beyond the law’s provision for vouchers of up to $6,000 for up to 15,000 students a year.
The case centers on the part of the South Carolina’s constitution that says “no money shall be paid from public funds nor shall the credit of the State or any of its political subdivisions be used for the direct benefit of any religious or other private educational institution.”
Lawyers who think the program is illegal said giving the private schools public money is a direct benefit even if the program allows students to pay fees or transportation to attend a public school outside of their district.
“It’s all in a trust fund – it’s all in a state controlled trust fund,” attorney Ramya Ravindran told the justices.
But supporters of the new law said the trust fund is key. The money goes to parents, who get to make a decision on where to spend it instead of state government directly paying the private schools themselves.
“The Rosetta Stone of this case is to figure out who the direct beneficiary is,” said Jim Gilliam, an attorney for Republican House Speaker Murrell Smith.
Smith last week proposed a bill that would make the program open to all students, eliminating by 2027 what was going to be a $120,000 family income cap and a cap on 2% of the school age population, or about 15,000 students.
The bill that would also eliminate state audits for private schools getting the money and not require them to give their students the same standardized tests as public school students as a comparison passed a subcommittee Tuesday and will likely head to the House floor Thursday.
Senate Majority Leader Shane Massey said last week he wants to see what the state Supreme Court says and give the program some time to operate before changing things.
“Before you look at expanding it, you need to makes sure this one is going to work,” Massey said.
The law is part of a nationwide movement. Groups that study the programs report that as many as 16 states have some form of the vouchers.
A second possible problem with the South Carolina law for supporters is the law has the state Education Superintendent running the program. The constitution calls her the “chief administrative officer of the public education system.” The state says that doesn’t prohibit her from expanding her duties.
“How can the legislature require that individual get involved in private education?” asked James Lockemy, a retired Court of Appeals chief judge sitting in on this case.
Allowing parents to spend public money on private schools has been a two decade effort that ran through three governors, four House speakers and five education superintendents in a state where Republicans have been consolidating and expanding their power.
The justices Tuesday peppered both sides with questions. Chief Justice Donald Beatty was especially skeptical of the new law, mentioning an earlier state Supreme Court ruling that the governor could not send COVID relief money directly to private schools.
“Obviously, we weren’t convincing then, were we?” Beatty said introducing Wednesday’s case.
Later, Education Department attorney Miles Coleman said no private school sees the new money as a benefit when a state agency gets additional oversight and access to their books.
“This money isn’t even enough to cover what we think is the cost as a state of education. It’s not some sort of largess or boon to the recipient,” Coleman said of the program’s $90 million price tag.
“$90 million is not a boon?” asked Beatty, who earlier in the arguments said that would be enough money to hire 2,200 public school teachers, adding “yet we want to shift all this money to private schools to keep them afloat.”
The justices made no decision Wednesday and will issue a ruling at a later date.
veryGood! (774)
Related
- The Daily Money: Spending more on holiday travel?
- Ukraine's Zelenskyy tells Sean Penn in 'Superpower' documentary: 'World War III has begun'
- Can't find the right Clorox product? A recent cyberattack is causing some shortages
- How a rural Alabama school system outdid the country with gains in math
- Sonya Massey's father decries possible release of former deputy charged with her death
- Gov. Healey of Massachusetts announces single use plastic bottle ban for government agencies
- Édgar Barrera, Karol G, Shakira, and more lead Latin Grammy nominations
- Most Americans are confident in local police, but many still want major reforms
- Meet first time Grammy nominee Charley Crockett
- More Than 150 Protesters Arrested in New York City While Calling on the Federal Reserve to End Fossil Fuel Financing
Ranking
- Intellectuals vs. The Internet
- Tia Mowry Shares Dating Experience With “Ghosting and Love Bombing” After Cory Hardrict Breakup
- Vatican considers child sexual abuse allegations against a former Australian bishop
- UN dramatically revises down death toll from Libya floods amid chaotic response
- Sonya Massey's father decries possible release of former deputy charged with her death
- Florida family welcomes third girl born on the same day in four years
- Indian lawmakers attend their last session before moving to a new Parliament building
- Alabama Barker Reveals the Best Beauty Advice Stepmom Kourtney Kardashian Has Given Her
Recommendation
Selena Gomez's "Weird Uncles" Steve Martin and Martin Short React to Her Engagement
Alabama Barker Reveals the Best Beauty Advice Stepmom Kourtney Kardashian Has Given Her
North Korea says Kim Jong Un is back home from Russia, where he deepened ‘comradely’ ties with Putin
'We're going to wreck their economy:' UAW president Shawn Fain has a plan. Will it work?
Meta releases AI model to enhance Metaverse experience
Olivia Rodrigo's Ex Zack Bia Weighs In On Whether Her Song Vampire Is About Him
Travis Scott questioned in Astroworld festival deposition following wave of lawsuits
Former Belarusian operative under Lukashenko goes on Swiss trial over enforced disappearances